Back to Blog
Policy & CompliancePolicy Update10 min read
Perky BenefitsPerky Benefits

Is Your Workplace Nursery Scheme HMRC-Compliant? What Employers Need to Check

Published on . Last updated on . See changes

In July 2024 HMRC clarified how it applies the partnership rules for workplace nurseries, and warned that it never approves schemes. Arrangements that miss the legal conditions do not qualify for the tax exemption, and simply paying a nursery for places is not enough. Here is what compliance actually requires – and what is at stake if your arrangement does not qualify.


Not all workplace nursery schemes are equal – and HMRC's position on this has become significantly clearer. Where employers have entered arrangements with external providers that do not meet the statutory definition of employer-provided childcare, HMRC does not recognise the tax exemption. The consequences for employers operating non-qualifying schemes include a P11D liability on the benefit value and potential NI exposure on amounts that were treated as exempt. With the new tax year approaching on 6 April 2025, now is the time to verify that your arrangement meets the legal standard – before it becomes a problem that HMRC identifies first. (Updated 16 October 2026: the April 2025 date this post was written for has passed. The law and HMRC's guidance on the exemption have not changed since publication, so the checks below still apply.)

What HMRC's Scrutiny of Workplace Nursery Schemes Means in Practice

The workplace nursery exemption has existed since 1990, and interest in it has grown in recent years as childcare costs have risen. HMRC's guidance – set out in its Employment Income Manual at EIM22001–EIM22007, with a section on commercially marketed schemes at EIM21970–EIM21973 – is clear on the conditions that must be met for the exemption to apply.

If HMRC finds that an arrangement does not qualify, tax and National Insurance become due on the value of the childcare for every employee who took part – potentially going back several years. Depending on how the scheme was set up, the employer pays some or all of it (see 'The Financial Stakes' below). For employers with meaningful participation rates, that exposure is not negligible. The administrative burden of correcting payroll records and P11D filings is also material.

The risk is real, even if it is not widespread. In July 2024 HMRC said it believes the majority of workplace nursery partnership schemes meet the requirements. However, it had been alerted to a small number of scheme operators advertising their services as HMRC-approved where the partnership requirements were not met. HMRC also said it will never give a business approval to advertise a scheme as tax compliant (Agent Update 121). Employers cannot assume that paying for a service described as a 'workplace nursery scheme' means they are protected.

The Legal Threshold: What 'Financial and Management Responsibility' Actually Requires

The exemption applies only if all four conditions in section 318 ITEPA 2003 are met. The child must be the employee's child or stepchild (maintained at least partly at their expense), live with them, or be a child they have parental responsibility for. The care must meet the registration rules and not be provided in a private home. The scheme must be open to employees generally, or to employees generally at a particular site. And the premises must be made available either by the employer alone or under a partnership that includes the employer. An employer that provides the premises itself can contract a commercial nursery business to provide the care. Under a partnership, the employer must also be 'wholly or partly responsible for financing and managing the provision of the care' (section 318(7)(c) ITEPA 2003), as explained in HMRC's guidance at EIM22007. Simply paying a third party for places does not meet that test.

Under the partnership route, the arrangement must show that the employer:

  • Accepts real financial responsibility for the nursery – a genuine share of the cost of running it and of the financial risk, including any losses. In HMRC's words, the employer 'must accept material financial responsibility', which 'requires more than purchasing places at a commercial nursery and making contributions to fixed costs' (Agent Update 121, July 2024).

  • Has a meaningful role in the management or governance of the provision – for example, through a partnership with a local authority, another employer, or a provider with whom the employer has a genuine contractual stake in the operation.

  • Provides the place to the employee as a benefit from their employment – not as a commercial transaction between the employee and the nursery provider.

The distinction between qualifying and non-qualifying arrangements can be nuanced, and employers should seek professional confirmation that their specific arrangement meets the standard.

Three Arrangement Types That Do Not Qualify for Tax Exemption

1. Employer pays a fee to a nursery 'aggregator' for discounted places

HMRC's guidance gives a similar arrangement as an example of one that does not qualify (EIM22007, Example 1). The employer pays a third party that has negotiated discounted rates with a network of nurseries. The employer has no financial or management relationship with the nurseries themselves. The employee receives a discounted rate, but the exemption does not apply because the employer is purchasing a commercial service, not providing childcare.

2. Employer subsidises the employee's nursery fees directly

Where an employer gives an employee cash, or pays them back for nursery fees, this counts as earnings – PAYE income tax and Class 1 NI are due through payroll – not employer-provided childcare. The distinction is whether the employer is providing a nursery place or contributing to the cost of one that the employee has independently arranged. The latter does not qualify for the exemption. Childcare vouchers follow separate rules: they are tax-free only up to a weekly limit, and only for employees who joined a voucher scheme on or before 4 October 2018.

3. Salary sacrifice payments described as nursery scheme contributions

Some providers structure their offering as a salary sacrifice arrangement where the sacrificed amount is described as funding a nursery place. Where the employer does not have the required financial and management relationship with the nursery, the salary sacrifice structure does not convert a non-qualifying arrangement into a qualifying one. The exemption is determined by the nature of the provision, not the payment mechanism.

Download our workplace nursery compliance checklist

Assess your current arrangement against HMRC's requirements.
Download

What a Compliant Scheme Structure Looks Like

A qualifying workplace nursery arrangement typically takes one of the following forms:

  • The employer provides the nursery on premises it makes available itself – part of its existing premises, or premises it acquires or rents. It can run the nursery itself or contract a commercial nursery business to provide the care.

  • The employer enters a partnership arrangement with one or more other employers to jointly operate a nursery, with documented shared financial and management responsibility.

  • The employer enters a partnership with a local authority, voluntary body or nursery provider under which it shares the cost and financial risk of running the nursery and takes a real part in managing it – not merely a contractual right to purchase places.

In each case, the legal substance must match the description. The partnership or management role must be genuine and documented, not nominal. HMRC will look at the actual relationship, not the label applied to it. Employers who are uncertain whether their current arrangement meets this standard should seek a written legal or tax opinion before continuing to treat the benefit as exempt.

The Financial Stakes: What Employers Risk if a Scheme Fails HMRC Scrutiny

The financial exposure from a non-qualifying nursery arrangement depends on the number of participating employees, the value of the benefit provided, and the number of years the arrangement has been in place. HMRC can normally assess income tax for up to four years after the end of the tax year concerned – six years if the underpayment was careless and 20 if it was deliberate. Unpaid National Insurance can generally be recovered for six years from when it was due – longer in Scotland, or where there has been deliberate concealment or fraud.

The liabilities would typically include:

  • Where the salary sacrifice works but the nursery does not qualify, the place is a benefit in kind, reported on the P11D. Each employee pays income tax on its value, and the employer pays Class 1A NI on the same amount. For a place given through salary sacrifice, the value is the higher of the salary given up and the cost of the place.

  • Where the sacrifice does not work – for example, because the employee can give up the place and return to full salary at any time – or the employee holds the contract with the nursery, the amounts count as pay. The employer must then account for PAYE income tax and Class 1 NI (employee and employer).

  • Interest on late payment of the amounts due.

  • Potentially, penalties for careless or deliberate non-compliance, depending on the employer's conduct.

Take an employer with 50 participating employees, all basic-rate taxpayers, each receiving a benefit valued at £5,000 a year (£250,000 in total). At 2024/25 rates, the cost depends on how HMRC treats the scheme. Taxed as a benefit in kind, the employer pays Class 1A NI of £34,500 a year (13.8%), and the employees owe £50,000 of income tax between them (20%). In the worst case, where PAYE and Class 1 NI apply, the total is £104,500 a year (20% tax, 8% employee NI and 13.8% employer NI). It is more if the employer bears its employees' share, because that payment is itself taxable. Interest and any penalties come on top, and these figures are illustrative. That is before any professional fees associated with responding to an HMRC enquiry. (Updated 16 October 2026: employer Class 1 and Class 1A NI rose from 13.8% to 15% on 6 April 2025. At 2025/26 and 2026/27 rates, the figures above become £37,500 a year of Class 1A in the benefit-in-kind case and £107,500 a year in the worst case.) The financial stakes make this a Finance Director conversation as well as an HR one. The benefit may have been implemented by the people team, but the tax risk sits on the employer's balance sheet.

The Legitimate Saving

For employers who do operate a qualifying workplace nursery scheme, the financial benefit to employees is significant. A basic-rate taxpayer saves income tax and NI on the full value of the benefit – for a nursery place worth £15,000 per year, the annual saving can be several thousand pounds. For a higher-rate taxpayer, the saving is greater. Getting the structure right is worth the effort.

Questions to Ask Your Current Nursery Scheme Provider Before April

If you are currently operating a workplace nursery arrangement, ask your provider to confirm in writing:

  1. Does our arrangement meet the conditions for the workplace nursery exemption in section 318 ITEPA 2003, as explained in HMRC's guidance at EIM22001–EIM22007?

  2. Do we, as the employer, have financial and management responsibility for the nursery provision – and can you evidence this in the contractual documentation?

  3. Is our financial contribution going directly to the nursery operation – or is it a fee for access to a network or platform?

  4. What is the governance structure of our arrangement – who manages the nursery, and what is our role in that management?

  5. Has this arrangement been reviewed by a qualified tax adviser in the last 12 months?

  6. If HMRC were to open an enquiry into this arrangement, what documentation could be provided to demonstrate compliance?

A provider that cannot answer these questions clearly and in writing is a provider whose scheme structure should be examined carefully before the new tax year. (Updated 16 October 2026: these questions were written for the run-up to the April 2025 tax year. They apply equally now, and are worth asking again whenever your provider, contract or premises change.)

Frequently Asked Questions

Change log

    • Added notes that the April 2025 tax year this post was written for has passed. The law and HMRC's guidance on the workplace nursery exemption have not changed since publication, so the checks still apply.

    • The downloadable workplace nursery compliance checklist now uses 2026/27 rates. The edition accurate at the date this post was published is archived here.

    • Added a note to the 50-employee example: employer Class 1 and Class 1A National Insurance rose from 13.8% to 15% on 6 April 2025. At 2025/26 rates the example's figures become £37,500 a year of Class 1A in the benefit-in-kind case and £107,500 a year in the worst case.


Thanks for reading!

More Posts